Popular interlibrary loan service cancelled at Huntsville Public Library due to government cuts



It’s a much-loved service at Huntsville Public Library, but interlibrary loans will be no more as of April 26 thanks to budget cuts by the Ford government.

Interlibrary loans are one of the services overseen by the Southern Ontario Library Service (SOLS), which learned that their funding had been cut by 50 per cent in the provincial budget tabled earlier this month. SOLS serves public libraries in almost 200 municipalities as far north as Muskoka. Their counterpart, the Ontario Library Service – North, also had its funding cut by 50 per cent.

In a statement on April 18, SOLS CEO, Barbara Franchetto, announced that the interlibrary loan service, which allows patrons to borrow items from other libraries for pick up at their local library, would be cancelled. “I know this is very sad and disappointing news but given the enormity of the cut to our operating budget, there is no alternative,” she wrote. “Even under our previous budget allocation, it was becoming difficult to sustain the service because of ever increasing operating costs.”

The service will be missed by many patrons at Huntsville Public Library (HPL), said CEO and chief librarian, Deborah Duce. She said that last year HPL received over 4,000 requests for items from other libraries and lent out just over 3,000 to them, and HPL patrons borrowed almost 2,800 items from other libraries in the SOLS system.

“The Minister of Tourism, Culture and Sport said that the cut isn’t going to impact the day-to-day operations of the library,” said Duce. “It is going to have a definite impact on people.”

People like seniors looking for a large print book that might be out of print or not part of the HPL collection. Or homeschoolers looking for more information on a topic than what the library has available on its shelves. Or members of HPL’s three book clubs who borrow the books to read so they don’t incur the expense of buying every one.

People who read for pleasure enjoyed having the option of borrowing books beyond what is available on the HPL stacks.

Even people who like to watch DVDs could be affected. “We noticed that since Blockbuster closed, people really want DVDs,” said Duce. “We have a pretty good budget for DVDs but those are for new materials. If we have to cut into that budget to order old DVDs that people want, we will have to say no to some of that.”

Library staff are upset, said Duce, and they feel for the people they’ve gotten to know who will lose their jobs with these cuts. “We see the couriers three days a week, and they are three people who are going to be losing their jobs who are very helpful and kind. They deliver thousands of books, and it’s really hard that we’re not going to see them after this Friday.” They are just three of 24 who will loose their jobs as a result of the cuts.

There are currently almost 100 interlibrary loans out to HPL patrons which, if not returned by the end of the day on Thursday, will have to be shipped back to their individual lending libraries. “SOLS doesn’t have the money for that so we will have to assume the cost,” said Duce.

While no jobs at HPL will be lost as a result of the cuts, Duce said that there is one library in Muskoka that has a staff member whose sole job is interlibrary loans. “If she doesn’t have that job then what is that person going to do? It’s a huge deal.”

HPL staff met this morning to discuss ways to fill the hole left by the cancellation of the interlibrary loan service, “but I think that whatever we do, it will be just a little bit of dirt in the hole. It’s not going to fill that hole.”

They even broached the idea of a local van to deliver books between Muskoka libraries, at least. “But we’d have to buy a van and pay for maintenance and we’d have to pay for someone to drive it. That’s pretty expensive,” said Duce. “It’s better to just go with an efficient service that we already have in place and a database that works.”

SOLS was established in 1989 and delivers programs and services on behalf of the Ontario Minister of Tourism, Culture and Sport.

“I don’t remember a time when SOLS wasn’t an incredible support to libraries,” said Duce of the organization, which also provides support to libraries for board governance, training, professional development, and buying. “Interlibrary loans is one of the services that people use literally every day and I think it is going to have the biggest impact.”

Duce added, “I don’t see us getting more money from the government to increase our collection development budget. Funding to public libraries has been on hold since the Harris government. They made cuts of almost 50 per cent so none of us have seen increases in our provincial funding. We can accept donations but where are we going to put them? We have limited shelf space. Do we reduce budgets in other areas to cover that?”

She will be submitting a letter to the Minister of Tourism, Culture and Sport and MPP Norm Miller “expressing our sorrow and letting them know what the impact is.” She will also be asking for Huntsville Council’s support of the letter.

“It’s such a valuable resource,” said Duce. “I don’t think people take it for granted. I think there will be a lot more disappointment. I think we’re all just going to have to figure out how to get the government to change their mind on this cut.”

Don’t miss out on Doppler! Sign up for our free newsletter here.


  1. Unfortunately, libraries will just continue to become even easier targets in the future: There is an entire generation, who now receive all the information which they feel they need from cyberspace. Save their educational English requirements, reading novels or poetry for enjoyment, is a waste of time. Even many middle-aged people use the library only for the computers, DVD’s, newspapers, and magazines.
    Children’s books and programs; mature novels; Large Print novels; and non-fiction material for people who are uncomfortable with IT, or don’t own a computer; will continue to be popular (until the baby boomers shuffle off this mortal coil). But if young parents don’t read to their children, and instill a love of reading in their children, libraries will fall into disuse. I don’t particularly enjoy e-reading, and I selfishly hope that books preferably hard-cover will last my lifetime.
    Putting any faith in the generation, who seemingly had computers before they stopped teething, projects as a losing population.

  2. Karen Wehrstein on

    This enrages me. I have used the interlibrary loan service for the whole 28 years I’ve lived in Huntsville, usually to do research using books that I absolutely could not get in Huntsville, or any town close. What am I, and everyone else who has research needs the same as or *more* than mine, supposed to do — drive to Toronto every time? The Internet keeps getting deeper, yes, but it’s not deep enough, especially to *borrow* books (archive.org notwithstanding) instead of *buying* them.
    Glad to see Doug Ford’s poll numbers slipping as average Ontarians realize his agenda is about making our lives worse, not better.

  3. this is ludicrous; for all the small town library systems in the province how are they going to continue educating and entertaining people? I guess the goal is to have an entire populous that is not educated so that then they can continue voting for Ford Nation!

  4. I am house bound and use the library out reach service. Wonderful service, I’m wondering will this be next to go. I have used the Library for 30+ years and the staff are fantastic. I feel for them having to tell people the interlibrary service is no longer an option. Our towns in Ontario can’t afford to have Libraries like Toronto. Yes, Ford. Thank you. (sarcastic tone) He has money for Beer in corner stores, most subway lines but not for my town. The new election can’t come soon enough. Can’t anyone else stand up for small town Ontario? Where is my elected person?

  5. Amazing how everyone complains when their favorite service is cut but thinks the other person’s service should be cut instead of theirs. We are left with a debt in this province which our (and probably the next few) generations will never pay off. Is this the legacy we want to leave? Where would people suggest the money come from to keep all these nice things the previous governments (of all stripes) “gave” us? And please don’t say the rich should pay – in most cases they already are.
    Frankly, if the choice is cuts to health care and education or libraries (which are becoming dinosaurs due to the Internet), I know where my preferences lie. Ford is no saint, and I disagree with a lot he has (and probably will) do but at least he is trying to stem the rampant subsidies for special interest groups as much as he can. Anyone who has a better idea should put it forth instead of just complaining.

Leave a reply below. Comments without both first & last name will not be published. Your email address is required for validation but will not be publicly visible.