Commentary: Another odd MAHC decision



Everything has a tipping point. The most recent announcement by Phil Matthews, Muskoka Algonquin Healthcare (MAHC) Board Chair, of the selection of Dr. Abdel-Razek to become MAHC’s newest Chief of Staff (COS), may be the community’s tipping point. Dr. Abdel-Razek was chosen over the eminently qualified Dr. Roy Kirkpatrick.

This is not about Dr. Abdel-Razek’s qualifications. He continues to live and practice as the chief obstetrician and gynecologist in Orillia and has been accredited at MAHC since 2013 (serving mostly at MAHC’s Bracebridge site).

Dr. Roy Kirkpatrick has lived and worked in Muskoka his entire career. He is beloved and highly trusted by the entire community and highly respected by our medical practitioners. He has a long list of impressive credentials that are regional, national and global including:

  • awards from the OMA (Ontario Medical Association), most recently the 2018 Section Service Award for General Surgery;
  • advisory with the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada;
  • Associate Professor of the Northern Ontario School of Medicine;
  • an assessor for the College, an expert in rural medicine implementation; and
  • distinguished work with Doctors Without Borders and the Red Cross.

MAHC’s rationale for this odd decision cannot be known for certain. It seems obvious to us that they didn’t want a Muskoka-based doctor, regardless of excellent qualifications. It also appears that anyone who may not be ‘in-step with’ the board’s thinking would be discounted. We have written about this matter and other issues in past articles, pointing out this board’s lack of community regard and poor decisions that have caused significant community disruption and mistrust. They have done it again.

At the heart of this matter is MAHC’s flawed governance and accountability structure. A publicly accountable hospital board would have appointed Dr. Kirkpatrick as the Chief of Staff years ago, respecting the will of the people, while also saving precious time and scarce money.

Democracy is a wonderful thing—the opposite rarely serves the public interests adequately. Taxpayers pay for and are the users of our healthcare system—we are the shareholders in the true sense. Public election of board directors that properly represent their community is the only way forward now. We all have a responsibility to ensure that our interests are best served by individuals who know exactly who they represent. If they act otherwise, they will be removed by the community shareholders—democratically.

Time for real change is long overdue. Let’s demand it.

Ross Maund, former MAHC director and career senior corporate executive
Dave Wilkin, P.Eng. and former MAHC director

Don’t miss out on Doppler! Sign up for our free newsletter here.


  1. George Gilley on

    Is it not time that MAHC explain why Dr. Kirkpatrick was not considered a suitable candidate for this position? Or at the very least how a doctor continuing to live and work in Orillia is the proper choice.

  2. Roy, as he asked me to call him, was compassionate and caring. He was amazing in what was a scary thing for me. Surgery went well. Can’t say enough good things about him.

  3. Rob Millman on

    I have espoused several encomiums to Dr. Kirkpatrick in this “Comments” section. They are all valid, and worthy of repetition.
    This time, however, I have a personal axe to grind (when don’t I?). Recently, the MAHC Board was seeking two additional Directors. Without undue modesty, I aver that I was uniquely qualified for this position. Needless to say, I was not chosen (Perhaps, they read this section; and realized that I had a mind of my own). In any event, I questioned my lack of an interview, and they said that I didn’t have the credentials which they sought. With respect, this was patently untrue. They promised that they would publish the names of the successful candidates (with CV’s) to illustrate their transparency. To date, I have not seen such a disclosure anywhere.
    Please understand that this is not “sour grapes”. I have volunteered continuously in the healthcare area for the last 25 years; and simply felt that I had something to offer. Apparently, this is not a quality that they seek; as duplicated in their treatment of Dr. Kirkpatrick.

  4. There should have been no debate regarding Dr. Kirkpatrick being named to the Chief of Staff position at MAHC. His medical qualifications speak for themselves and he has earned the respect of patients and staff alike through his medical professionalism and leadership, commitment and dedication.

  5. Harolyn Hussain on

    Non of this makes any COMMON SENSE !!! A Doctor from here, who knows the hospital and the town and lives here and is qualified should be chosen over an outsider period.

  6. Kathryn Henderson on

    I have said the same thing every chance I get. Dr. Kirkpatrick should have been hired as Chief of Staff two years ago. How much work will this Orillia Dr contribute to Huntsville taxpayers while carrying on a practice and living in Orillia? A monkey even has enough common sense to pick Local. So Disappointed with Hospital Board and Town.

Leave a reply below. Comments without both first & last name will not be published. Your email address is required for validation but will not be publicly visible.