Sally-Barnes-Cartoon-ED.jpg

Listen Up! Stuff nobody wants!: A guest post by Sally Barnes | Commentary

Hugh Mackenzie is on a break from Listen Up!

By Sally Barnes

A simple cartoon sent by an internet friend has unleashed a torrent of responses from the horde of people suffering the torture of decluttering.

A bald old geezer leans on his walker, points to a garage crammed with a lifetime collection of stuff, and says to the kid next to him, “One day, Son,  all this will be yours.”

The cartoonist has hit a nerve with all those guilt-ridden adults like me (especially the elderly) who know they should get their houses in order before they sever their mortal coils and bequeath a mess to their survivors.

We are an aging society. As baby boomers retire, adults aged 65 and over will outnumber children under 15, and by 2030, nearly one in every four Canadians will be an older adult.  

With aging comes public policy concerns about who will pay the bills, and individuals face challenges such as downsizing and decluttering. 

All executors and heirs of estates should hope that their long-lost, eccentric old uncle is not one of the world’s great hoarders and a collector of poisonous snakes and insects.  

There are at least a thousand excuses for postponing decluttering. Some of it is just plain laziness and indecision. How else do you explain clinging to appliances and gadgets that broke decades ago, athletic equipment with missing parts, and home décor dating back to orange rugs, rabbit ears, fancy ashtrays, and Barbara Ann Scott dolls? 

There is the physical demand of hauling the stuff out of closets and backrooms and basements, attics and garages, but that doesn’t compare to the anguish of parting with a lifetime of memories and memorabilia.

At the best of times, parting with your stuff can be an emotional tug of war. It is especially gut-wrenching when you realize that nobody wants it. Admitting you can’t even give the stuff away hurts.

Your first pair of baby shoes may warm your heart, but who else wants them? This pales in comparison, of course, to a family who has the ashes of several dead relatives in urns over the fireplace and no takers for who gets them next. 

So many firsts….so little space. Kids now graduate from preschool, and these certificates pile up year after year as they move through the education system. Add to this the athletic and other awards.

Wedding dresses used to be boxed up and preserved. Not so much anymore, I’m told. Chances of a young bride today wanting to wear a family relic on her big day are slim to zero.

God bless those social agencies that welcome donations. Some will even come and pick them up. And for a handsome fee, private companies are more than happy to help with the task — especially if a house sale is involved and they get the listing. 

There’s a whole industry out there flourishing as a generation of baby boomers moves to retirement complexes and nursing homes and eventually perpetual care.

While my husband and I have no moving plans, we have been decluttering for many weeks now, recognizing that we aren’t getting any younger and have heard the lament of so many families struggling with generational change and the headaches involved.

First, we needed a plan. We named it Operation Overload, and it calls for lugging unwanted stuff to the garage, hiring someone to dispose of a load of paint and other hazardous materials, giving away what we can, and then bringing in a dumpster to dispose of the rest.

Excessive heat drove us inside on many days. A few health issues slowed us down. As the pile of stuff got higher, we learned the hard way that possessions we agonized over mean little or nothing to anyone else. 

In fact, Operation Overload was threatening what we hoped was a good reputation for hospitality.  Otherwise frequent visitors — friends and especially family — suddenly found better things to do than darken our doorway. Or if they did drop by, they would leave without notice and sneak out the back door. 

It finally dawned on us that they didn’t appreciate our generosity in trying to foist our stuff on them — in some cases, slipping a family heirloom or two into the back seat of their car that they discovered only after returning home. It was especially cheeky of us to interest kids in an item their parents were bound to refuse.  

At the time it was gifted to us, we thought a wall piece in the form of a fish was a real hoot. Clap your hands, and the sucker wiggles like you have him on a hook. No grandchild could pass this up. Several men have expressed an interest in adopting this aquatic specimen, but fear the wrath of their spouse if it comes home with them.  

We remain ever hopeful about other items and our sales pitch goes something like this:

  • This is your great grandmother’s favourite dish and she’d surely spin in her grave to know it will no longer be in the family.
  • Well, of course, the silver will need to be cleaned but maybe you’ll win a lottery and can pay someone to keep it shining.
  • The head is missing from Uncle Ted’s big pottery dog, but it’s here in a box somewhere, and a package of Gorilla Glue will easily fix that. 
  • You’ve always admired this painting — now it can be yours.
  • This collection of buttons and badges from countless election campaigns represents a lot of history and could be valuable someday. My favourite is This is My Billy Button. Whadya mean you’ve never heard of most of these guys? Neither did the voters at the time.
  • You have no idea how much fun you’ll have reading these old Eaton’s and Simpsons catalogues. The mice have been chewing away on them, and that only adds to the allure.

We’ve learned there is no interest in old time pieces and family diaries. We forgot that today’s kids don’t understand cursive writing and can only tell time in digital form. What’s going to happen to all the clocks and watches? Ending up in the same place as millions of old ashtrays, I suppose.

Misery enjoys company and we take comfort in knowing that we’re not alone in this decluttering stage of life. A friend, whose husband is an avid golfer, laments his fixation with used golf balls. The old duffer has shelves of empty paper milk cartons filled with balls he has salvaged from countless courses over many years. And he’s not done yet.

Meanwhile, we’ve run out of excuses and we’re about to fire up Operation Overload with a passion.

Family and friends will be notified when it’s safe to start visiting again. 

Sally Barnes has enjoyed a distinguished career as a writer, journalist, and author. Her work has been recognized in a number of ways, including receiving a Southam Fellowship in Journalism at Massey College at the University of Toronto.  A self-confessed political junkie, she has worked in the back rooms for several Ontario premiers. In addition to a number of other community contributions, Sally Barnes served a term as president of the Ontario Council on the Status of Women. She is a former business colleague of Doppler’s publisher, Hugh Mackenzie, and lives in Kingston, Ontario. You can find her online at sallybarnesauthor.com.

Don’t miss out on Doppler!

Sign up here to receive our email digest with links to our most recent stories.
Local news in your inbox so you don’t miss anything!

Click here to support local news

Join the discussion:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All comments are moderated. Please ensure you include both your first and last name and abide by our community guidelines. Submissions that do not include the commenter's full name or that do not abide by our community guidelines will not be published.

13 Comments

  1. John K. Davis says:

    Thanks Sally, what a timely piece, Debi and I decided we needed those electric platform beds to give us a better sleep.
    This started a domino effect that lasted for months. New beds require new paint and new rugs. If we are doing one bedroom perhaps we should really consider doing the other bedroom and bedroom converted to our offices.
    Awards from thirty years of working at one job and fifteen at another, combine that with groups we belong to or pictures of Muskoka Trustees I served with or Huntsville Councillors, or even the many Presidencies of organizations Debi and I served in and on. The folks at the Salvation Army Thrift Store got very use to Debi’s and my car.
    The shop and basement will have to wait until next year. The good news is, many people loved the treasures we left out front.

  2. Judith Lowes says:

    In the process of clearing out our personal possessions from our still For Sale Florida condo, we undertook an emotional triage on what came north and what went to local charitable organizations. Thank goodness condos are sold furnished in SW Florida.

    We shipped 40 + containers of prized possessions home to join the accumulated ‘stuff’ in our Huntsville home on the water; also still for sale, after 3 summers! After the Florida experience, I now do something every day, including contributions to charitable organizations, in anticipation of the day, maybe years down the road, when the lake house sells.

    We also have a policy that no one who visits leaves without taking something. Gifts out the door include tablecloths (I had about 30! ), bed sheets, towels, a bag of shells, DVD player and DVDs, VHF tapes…. You get the idea. It’s worked beautifully, so far, but, so far, none of our friends are downsizing or moving. Glad we’re ahead of the stampede.

  3. Jacqueline Bunting says:

    Unfortunately I’ve been having trouble finding places other than the dump to give stuff to. The thrift shops in my area are all getting quite picky.

  4. Peter Sanguinetti says:

    Sally, you are absolutely right but what about the situation when you find something and you think to yourself “I had better keep that it might come in useful one day”.. It never does of course but you never know..so you keep it just in case..

  5. nancy long says:

    I’ve been wanting a new couch. But what to do with the old one. Not quite the same as emptying a household, however it will go to the already overflowing landfill.

  6. Brian Tapley says:

    In the “old days” of things like Kodachrome slides (does anyone under 30 even know what these are?) I used to take lots of pictures, get the slides back and the family all sat around and looked at them on the big screen…ONCE, then they were “stored” and they still are.
    Gradually as photography went digital and a comment to a granddaughter asking “how many pictures she took that morning” got the answer “about 5000!” I realized that in reality nobody cares about pictures but the taker and in some special cases maybe some magazine, a cop or a lawyer.

    So now I use my smart phone as a tool. I take pictures of filters, nuts, bolts, nameplate data… really exciting stuff that is handy in the hardware store and I leave the beautiful landscapes and stuff to my memory. I figure if I’m the only one who is interested, these memories can keep me company until I can no longer remember them and at that time nothing matters anyway.

    Now as for the “really cool stuff” like snowmobiles from 1974, tractors from 1954 and a bulldozer from 1956… well this stuff is “different” and is kept in a dusty shed to be used occasionally and yes, my will is where I shall leave this stuff to torment some younger mechanical genius for 50 years of their life.

    Anybody want to make an offer on a 1974 Mercury Marquis Brougham with a 460 V-8 in it? If your serious you will find a way to tell me, of this I am sure.

  7. elizabeth stokes says:

    I’m in the process of doing this with my mother. Four bedroom two-story house downsizing to a one bedroom unit in a retirement home. It is still a very large space she is going into however…
    My one brother was all for just taking everything and donating it. My other brother nicely pointed out to him that the painting that was actually”flagged” as his had the last appraisal 10 years ago of over $7,500. He stopped dead on his focus of donating everything.
    What we have however decided is if it was something that was a value but we didn’t want it it would go into auction, as we are auctioning off a good portion of the household furniture, and whatever he gets at auction is automatically his.
    This has kept my mother happy and kept things moving forward where everybody’s still wins

  8. Susan Godfrey says:

    My intention is to downsize as much as I can and as soon as I can! I’m a minimalist anyway so not too much to get rid of but still.. I told my son “please feel free to park a green bin off the balcony and heave it all in”! Kids don’t want our stuff and they certainly can’t afford to “house” it with square footage being so expensive. I do hope he keeps his Nana’s china/silverware (he won’t) but it’s really not my decision because I’ll be dead so I won’t care anyway!

  9. Hugh Holland says:

    Thank you, Sally, for a good laugh about the eternal challenge of every generation.
    And its oh so true.

  10. Shirley Campbell says:

    I agree that with many people it’s a matter of just doing it. But remember, with some it’s is a mental disorder and they need professional help. They want to clean it up but struggle very deeply with it.

  11. Jim Boyes says:

    Good column Sally.
    We are in the exact same position.
    Just call the guys with the dumpster. Tell them to take everything. Be away somewhere while it happens.
    Enjoy your home coming!

  12. Anna-Lise Kear says:

    Sally, thank you for a moment of laughter, a moment of reality, and presenting the challenges of “transitioning”.

  13. Ralph Cliffe says:

    How true and well written! Looks like the garage my parents left me. I was grateful, but it took 3 garage sales and two trips to the local dump to clean up the estate. Now I am at that same age, looking at my own garage hoping I learned a lesson from my parents. Lots of luck!