• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • RSS
  • Twitter
Huntsville Doppler

Huntsville Doppler

Read Local

  • Home
    • All Stories
    • Community Guidelines
  • COVID-19
  • News
  • Commentary
  • Community
  • Business
    • Real Estate
    • Professionally Speaking
  • Sports
  • Obituaries
  • Lifestyle
    • Contests and Deals
    • Entertainment
    • Extraordinary People
    • Feature
    • This is Huntsville | Videos
    • Wayback Wednesday
    • Our Town with Grant Nickalls | Archive
  • Events
    • Event Listings
    • Add Your Event
  • It’s All Good
  • Speak Up, Huntsville!
  • Subscribe
  • Support
You are here: Home / Commentary / COVID-19 and climate change: a good time to reflect | Commentary

COVID-19 and climate change: a good time to reflect | Commentary

By Doppler Submitted On April 13, 2020 Commentary

Share on Facebook
Facebook
Tweet about this on Twitter
Twitter
Share on LinkedIn
Linkedin
Email this to someone
email
Print this page
Print

 

Main image: These satellite images show reduced nitrogen dioxide (NO2) levels before, during and after China’s New Year holiday for 2019 and 2020. These images reveal less NO2 emitted during the weeks of China’s lockdown. (CREA analysis of NASA OMI satellite data via cbc.ca)

By Hugh Holland

What do COVID-19 and climate change have to do with each other? Quite a bit, it turns out.

  • Both are caused and amplified by unintentional gaps in understanding and judgement.
  • Both are equal opportunity threats with no respect for race, color, wealth or religion.
  • Both are met with initial denial followed by mass panic.

How are they different?

  • COVID-19 is fast moving with immediate impact. It was first named by the WHO on Feb. 11, 2020.
  • Climate change is slow moving with less immediate but more wide-sweeping impact. It was first named 32 years ago in 1988.
  • COVID-19 and other pandemics will impact eight billion people and our economy.
  • Climate change will impact eight billion people, our economy, our infrastructure and our environment.

What can we learn from COVID-19 that can help us mitigate climate change?

  • Both are complex and wide-reaching threats that require us to follow the best science available rather than unsubstantiated hunches and advice from those with conflicting agendas.
  • COVID-19 demonstrates the massive challenge of reducing emissions to target levels. Emissions over China were temporarily reduced only 25 per cent by shutting down their entire economy except for home heating and lighting and emergency services.
  • For both, prevention is much cheaper and less disruptive than a cure.
  • Solutions to both require a deliberate systematic approach with timing based on realistic projections of accurate data. Neither can be solved overnight, and climate change will take much longer.
  • Panic and extremism are not helpful in solving either problem.
    • Individual and local hoarding of medical supplies, resources and food is counterproductive to coping with a pandemic.
    • Extreme ideas about killing fossil fuels immediately or about extending them indefinitely are both counterproductive to mitigating climate change.

In case you find all of this a bit depressing, let’s talk about what could be done to mitigate both threats.

  • Develop a realistic timetable for the transition to clean energy along the lines of the following graph. The hatched area shows a potential energy shortage if the rate of reduction of fossil fuels exceeds the rate of replacement. The many opportunities for carbon absorption must also be an important part of the solution. Like stopping COVID-19, we already know how to do it, but developing public understanding and acceptance, and the political will is the hardest part.

 

  • If we should learn anything from COVID-19 and climate change, it is that we are all in this together. But the continuous ratcheting up of military spending and increasingly destructive weapons is driving nations farther apart. NATO’s annual defense budget is already 10 times Russia’s and five times China’s. American hubris and the resulting pressure to keep increasing the NATO budget, and Trump’s much touted increase of over $100 billion per year to the US defense budget serves only to provoke both Russia and China to increase their military budgets (even though neither Russia or China or even the US can afford it), to tempt all to use their new military toys, to increase the threat of regional wars, and to reduce the ability of every state to cope with the potentially bigger threats of  global pandemics and global climate change.
  • The Obama administration established a National Pandemic Response Team in 2015, after the 2014 Ebola epidemic. How ironic that Trump fired that Team in 2018 to save money because he thought they had nothing to do, and then he increased military spending by over $100 billion.
  • US foreign policy has been a patchwork of some very good and some very questionable actions. No race or country is inherently bad, but some have been provoked into practising bad behavior. The problem with long-standing disputes is that hardly anyone on either side remembers who threw the first stone. They just keep on throwing.
  • For example, the US-Iran dispute started in 1953 when Iran elected its first democratic government that tried to get a fair share of the benefits of their large oil reserves. (That should sound familiar to Albertans who are currently selling their oil to the US at a multi-billion-dollar discount.) In response, MI6 and the CIA organized a coup and Iran has been an autocracy ever since. It takes much more courage to try to end a long-standing dispute as Obama did with the Iran nuclear agreement, than to escalate the dispute as Trump has done with disastrous results that will take decades to repair.
  • Aggressive action by one side makes it easier for leaders of the opposing side to persuade their population of a need to respond. Instead, NATO could drop the target contribution of NATO countries from 2 per cent of GDP to 1 per cent of GDP and use the $500 billion in annual savings toward global efforts to mitigate future pandemics and climate change. The latest thinking is that to avoid the worst effects of climate change, we need to achieve net-zero emissions (emissions less absorption) by 2050. $500 million per year from now until 2050 could contribute $15 US trillion to that effort. That’s $20,000,000,000,000 Canadian dollars! That will not likely be enough, but when coupled with similar reductions in military spending by Russia and China, and the resulting goodwill, it could well be the single biggest contribution to the mitigation of pandemics and climate change. What else can be cut to find that amount of money?  Shelter, food, education, and health care are already underfunded in many countries including the biggest players, the US, Russia, and China.
  • Canada could buy one less F35 fighter jet and use the $100 US million in savings to create and maintain the strategic resources needed to deal with the next pandemic virus and / or extreme weather event.

 

Don’t miss out on Doppler!

Sign up here to receive our email digest with links to our most recent stories.
Local news in your inbox three times per week!


Reader Interactions

4 Comments

  1. Rob Millman says

    April 14, 2020 at 9:10 am

    Of course, Russia and Saudi Arabia could stop their price war on oil. It does nothing to incentivize the production of efficient, hybrid vehicles. The only hope for a reduction in U.S. military spending would be a Biden victory in November (and even Trump’s abysmal handling of the pandemic, has only increased his popularity). Furthermore, he is doling out the preventative monies preferentially; to key states he needs for their electoral votes.

    Covid-19 (first and second spike) should run their course under four more years of Trump; but any American action vis-a-vis the climate crisis will nonexistent.

  2. Sandy McLennan says

    April 14, 2020 at 9:31 am

    yes

  3. Ray Vowels says

    April 14, 2020 at 9:42 am

    Hugh this all sounds good or bad depending in what part your reading . In reality all we have to do is look up on a clear night and see all the stars most of them you could not see when the air was filled with planes not now in a few weeks the sky is clearing up so that should be one lesson we learn from this shut down we can get along without all the air travel and the pollution they create.

    As far as global warming it’s not going to stop no matter what we do it’s been going on for 10.000 or more years and nothing we do will stop it maybe slow it but thats about all. So we just better learn to adapt to it and learn to like what it brings.

  4. Anna-Lise Kear says

    April 16, 2020 at 1:02 pm

    Mr. Vowels, please educate yourself a bit more about climate change. Sir, you cannot visibly “see” the corona virus, but do you doubt its existence? Of course not, because you “see and hear about” the effects of this tiny virus on humankind. Are you self-isolating to slow the spread of this virus to others? Of course you are.
    Your attitude towards the pandemic does not seem defeatist, so why does your attitude towards climate change seem so defeatist?
    Mr. Holland, an excellent article, with good information. Thank you, I have learned something new.
    Political parties and leaders with little value/political will for science (climate, earth, biological) are not helping us. Thank you for listening.

Join the discussion (please include your first and last name and follow our community guidelines): Cancel reply

All comments are moderated. Please ensure you include both your first and last name and abide by our community guidelines.

Primary Sidebar

Latest Commentary Pieces

Former Governor General Julie Payette in Ottawa on Sept. 23, 2020 (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press)

Listen Up! A week packed with issues | Commentary

January 24, 2021 Leave a Comment

An aerial view of Langmaid's Island in Lake of Bays (supplied)

Protecting our natural heritage: The Langmaid’s Island story | Commentary

January 21, 2021 6 Comments

Shutdown necessary to control COVID-19 and protect healthcare: MPP Norm Miller

January 20, 2021 11 Comments

Recent Stories

Former Governor General Julie Payette in Ottawa on Sept. 23, 2020 (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press)

Listen Up! A week packed with issues | Commentary

January 24, 2021

"Grandad" in process, by Zoë Valentine

Art Fx #4: “Grandad” by Zoë Valentine

January 24, 2021

Local anti-racism advocacy group responds to George Floyd comment made at District meeting | Letters

January 23, 2021

Footer

About Doppler

Established in 2015 by a bunch of local news hounds, Doppler strives to be the go-to source for people wanting to know more about what is going on in Huntsville and the surrounding community.

We strive to provide local news that is relevant and timely. We also look to tell local stories that inspire, inform and engage.

Notice the persistent use of the word local? Our mantra is local. From features on local people doing extraordinary things, to local business spotlights, news and sports coverage, all supplemented by provocative opinion pieces on topics near and far, we are working hard for you.

Feel free to drop us a line at huntsville@doppleronline.ca and tell us how we are doing, what you would like to see more of, or to just say ‘Hi’.

Thank you for reading Doppler.

Huntsville Doppler – READ LOCAL

Recent Comments

  • Bev Belanger on Art Fx #4: “Grandad” by Zoë Valentine
  • Sandy McLennan on MTO seeks feedback on rail and bus service between Toronto, North Bay and NE Ontario
  • Bess Coleman on Local resident delighted by unusual cloud formation
  • Bill Beatty on Significant multi-residential development proposed for Huntsville’s northeastern urban area now before planning tribunal
  • Ron Baker on Significant multi-residential development proposed for Huntsville’s northeastern urban area now before planning tribunal
  • Peter Crozier on Significant multi-residential development proposed for Huntsville’s northeastern urban area now before planning tribunal
  • Wayne Sinclair on Committee turns down moratorium on new development in Huntsville’s northeast urban area
  • Anna-Lise Kear on Speak Up, Huntsville!

Copyright © 2021 ·Doppler · Log in
  • About
  • Support Local News
  • Community Guidelines
  • Advertising
  • Contact
  • Subscribe